Health Care Debate: Further Reading
Building on this previous post …
Patient Protection And Affordable Care Act, 2010
- A Summary of the Health Care Reform Bill — CBSnews.com
- Bill information at Senate.gov
- Bill summary and information at Thomas, Library of Congress
- Bill summary, history, and related information at Wikipedia
- Summary of Patient Protection And Affordable Care Act — Wall Street Journal Online
Defenses of the Bill
Individual Mandate: Unconstitutional?
- Shikha Dalmia, "That Darn Mandate: Will Americans be forced to buy health insurance?" — Forbes.com
- Glen Whitman, "Hazards of the Individual Health Care Mandate" — Cato Institute
- The Individual Mandate in Obamacare is Unconstitutional — Heritage Foundation
- "Is the Health Care Law Unconstitutional?" — RoomforDebate, NYtimes.com
Individual Mandate: An Idea Some Conservatives Once Supported
- Individual Mandate was Once a GOP Idea — Associated Press
- "Quote of the Day: the Individual Mandate" — MotherJones
- Bruce Bartlett, "HCR — A Republican Idea?"
- Jonathan H. Adler, "Was the Individual Mandate a “Republican Idea”?"
Mitt Romney, "My Plan is Conservative … No more free riders."
Medical Anti-Intrusion Arguments
Fiscal Responsibility Arguments
- Robert Samuelson, "With health bill, Obama has sown the seeds of a budget crisis" — WashingtonPost.com
- Rebuttal to Robert Samuelson on Economics of Health Care Reform — Econbrowser
- George F. Will, "A battle won, but a victory?" — WashingtonPost
- Health Care Reform Cost Visualization — 10,000 Pennies – YouTube
Anti-Taxation, Individual Liberty Perspectives
Sean Hannity: How to Defeat the Obama Agenda
- At 3:14 — libertarian quotation from Thomas Jefferson, 1801
- At 7:50 – 7:57 — Hannity combines positive references to Tea Party and "Tim McVeigh wannabes"
Video from TeaPartyExpress.org
Mixed Views on Anti-Reform Rhetoric and Politics
With or Without Health Reform, We Pay for Others’ Bad Habits – NYTimes.com
On political rhetoric and conservative strategy:
- David Frum, Waterloo — FrumForum, March 2010
- "[T]he gap between this plan and traditional Republican ideas is not very big. The Obama plan has a broad family resemblance to Mitt Romney’s Massachusetts plan. It builds on ideas developed at the Heritage Foundation in the early 1990s that formed the basis for Republican counter-proposals to Clintoncare in 1993-1994."
- David Frum, Excerpts of "Waterloo" posted in column at CNN.com
- David Frum, Why Rush is Wrong, March 2009 — Newsweek.com
- David Frum loses position at The American Enterprise Institute — FrumForum.com
- Tunku Varadarajan, "The Conservative the Right Loves to Hate" — against David Frum — TheDailyBeast.com
- Anne Applebaum, "Nasty Parties Don’t Win Elections" — Slate.com
- "After Firing, Bloggers Side With David Frum" — AtlanticWire
Accusations of Rhetorical Extremism and Potential Violence
- Frank Rich, "The Rage is Not About Healthcare" — New York Times
- Thomas Friedman, "A Tea Party Without Nuts" — New York Times
- "Sarah Palin posts political hit list on Facebook" — Examiner.com
- "Twitter used to call for Obama assassination over health care bill" — Examiner.com
- The Resurgence of Hate Groups in America — The Diane Rehm Show
David Frum on Barack Obama’s Rhetoric
Quotes and Notes:
- "Barack Obama is the most verbally exact politician I have ever seen." — states things with careful precision, and allows others to infer what he may not have actually said — (a knack sometimes referred to as "strategic ambiguity").
- At 10:45 – approx. 2 min segment: "Barack Obama has mastered one of the most fundamental rules of television today: He who loses his temper loses the debate … His stature is elevated by his refusal to criticize … [While] people like Rush Limbaugh and Newt Gingrich are marginalized."
